Skip to main content

Criticism


Our writing “…belongs to anyone that wants to read or criticize it.” 
Stephen King - On Writing





It was bound to happen. I suppose it happens to all writers at some point. At first, when I saw it, I was angry and it really got my blood boiling. My heart started racing. What was it? The first overtly critical, harshly directed, publicly ridiculing of something I wrote.

My first response was to lash out, respond and retaliate in some way. But then, I remembered something Stephen King had writing in his book, On Writing.

King said that our first draft should be written with the door closed. It should be for us. We tell the story to ourselves. We are our first audience. When we rewrite it should be with the door open. We should write with our audience in mind as we rewrite. When we “get it right”, when we are happy with the story, with the final product, we share it with the world. When we “get it right”, it becomes fair game for praise or criticism.

There are two participants (so far) in this criticism. I checked their profiles to qualify them to be critical. I checked to see what they had written, if anything. What had they creatively produced? What I found surprised and saddened me. Nothing--they had not written anything. They are just consumers. I guess you would call them ‘trolls’. To quote a cliche “They don’t know art, but they know what they like”. I found nothing about them to believe they were qualified critics.

I thought more about what King had written and I decided to ask one of the critics that commented negatively why he didn't like what I had written. His response was to ask me why I cared what he thought. I replied that since he had taken the time to read and comment that I wanted to know why he didn't like what I had written. He has not responded.

What would my response be if they were bona fide critics? I've decided that any reader should be treated as if he were qualified to criticize. This has helped me think through, in a more thoughtful manner, my response to further criticisms. I’m sure they will come.

When I read another’s writing, I try to be as positive as possible. Unless the author has specifically asked me to comment or generally solicited comments about his or her writing, I stick to something positive. I try to encourage and comment on what the author has done well in his article or story.

I have had others comment about clarity or mention typos in my writing but as I said, this was the first attack on my efforts. I will be more open and more prepared for criticism in the future. If either of my two critics is reading this, I just want to say, “Thanks for all of your help!”

What has been your response to negative treatment or criticism to something you have written?

Photo by Martorell

If you enjoyed this article, you might enjoy reading my other writing site Hupages.



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Stephen King’s “What Writing Is”

On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft    “What Writing Is” I have written an article in another Blog summarizing several sections in Stephen King's book. This article is about another section of his intriguing book. Stephen King’s “What Writing Is” 4. What Writing Is —pp.103-107 Stephen King suggests: “Telepathy, of course.” Writing is telepathy. Telepathy is defined as “the transmission of information from one person to another without using any of our known sensory channels or physical interaction.” In modern fiction and science fiction, many superheroes and super-villains are endowed with telepathic abilities. The term was coined in 1882 by the classical scholar Frederic W. H. Myers, a founder of the Society for Psychical Research, and has remained more popular than the earlier expression thought-transference. (Wikipedia) Writing about telepathy, King suggests that we are “downstream on the time-line”. We are in the here-and-now and as he writes from the past, he

old friends

old friends searched online for former friends surprised to see untimely ends friends, their spouses, moms and dads sad to see the deaths they had the inexorable tick and tock of time, leads us all to fields, sublime through twisting, turning hands of fate, soon we'll all be known as "late" years roll on, time is passed no one knows how long it lasts each life is counted out by days as friends we oft go separate ways friend's faces show the lines of age as each one turns his separate page fools fleeting time waits for no man eighty years our lives may span so count your days with special care for who knows how, who knows where our beating hearts will one day stop find old friends before they drop © 2014 ajwrites57 A Long ❤ ❤ ❤ Image adapted:  By SDRandCo via morguefile.com

Five of My Top Ten Greatest Novels

Five of My Top Ten Greatest Novels I recently joined a community on Google+ called "The 100 Greatest Novels of All Time". The moderator,   +Brandon Toropov  suggested we post our Top Ten Greatest Novels of All Time List. There are so many great books that I haven't yet read. There are so many authors that I have read that deserve to be mentioned and that I haven't chosen to be on my list (Tolstoy, Twain, James, A. Huxley, Orwell, Austen, Faulkner, J.F. Cooper, Koestler, Conrad, Kipling). Some of the authors whose works I chose had other novels to choose from for my list: Dostoevsky -- “the Bothers Karamazov” and “The Idiot”, Steinbeck -- “Of Mice and Men”, Tolkien -- “The Hobbit”, Hemmingway -- “A Farewell to Arms”, Bronte “Wuthering Heights”. I could go on and on for these authors. The novels I have chosen have altered my views about life or influenced my worldview in some way. Top Ten Greatest Novels Harper Lee - To Kill a Mockingbird  Fyodor Dostoevsky -